| Anne Shirley | Ella Mason |
| Marilla Cuthbert | Suzanna Miller |
| Matthew Cuthbert | Robert Demic |
| Diana Barry | Moira Buxton |
| Gilbert Blythe | Evan Jennison |
| Muriel Stacy | Stacy Raphael |
| Rachel Lynde | Aimee Diehl |
| Teddy Phillips | Shawn Kimball |
| Josie Pye | Josie Fox |
| Lucilla Harris/Mrs. Blewett | Rebecca Gould |
| Earl (Station Master/Mailman) | Scott Remick |
| Cecil Sloane | Brendan Gallivan |
| Rev. Bentley | Ben Allred |
| Valeda Spencer | Jessica Sabick |
| Elizabeth Barry | Melissa Grean Jennison |
| Clara Louise MacPherson | Phoebe Doan |
| Minnie Pye | Michelle Patton |
| Dorcas Sloane | Krista Siringo |
| Rev. Smythe-Hankinson | Stephen Lowe |
| Prissy Andrews | Kristen Pierce |
| Ralph Andrews | Luke Bleich |
| Julia Bell | Elise Lavigne |
| Tillie Boulter | Phoebe Raphael |
| Geri Boute | Hannah Gallivan |
| Ruby Gillis | Eryn Diehl |
| Sara Gillis | Sarah Heath |
| Davey Keith | Asa Baker-Rouse |
| Dora Keith | Avery Hohenschau |
| Ella Mae MacPherson | Quincy Sabick |
| Gertie Pye | Gwen Gero |
| Moody Spurgeon MacPherson | Sam Michaels |
| Barbara Shaw | Una Fonte |
| Carrie Sloane | Isabelle Gallivan |
| Charlotte "Charlie" Sloane | Lily James Roberts |
| Tommy Sloane | Sam Gallivan |